Working Papers

2018-14 | June 2019


Examining the Sources of Excess Return Predictability: Stochastic Volatility or Market Inefficiency?


We use a consumption based asset pricing model to show that the predictability of excess returns on risky assets can arise from only two sources: (1) stochastic volatility of model variables, or (2) departures from rational expectations that give rise to predictable investor forecast errors and market inefficiency. From an empirical perspective, we investigate whether 1-month ahead excess returns on stocks can be predicted using measures of consumer sentiment and excess return momentum, while controlling directly and indirectly for the presence of stochastic volatility. A variable that interacts the 12-month sentiment change with recent return momentum is a robust predictor of excess stock returns both in-sample and out-of-sample. The predictive power of this variable derives mainly from periods when sentiment has been declining and return momentum is negative, forecasting a further decline in the excess stock return. These are also periods when investors pay increased attention to the stock market, as measured by a Google search volume index. The resulting pessimism appears to motivate many investors to sell stocks, putting further downward pressure on stock prices, which contributes to a lower excess stock return over the next month.

Download PDF (pdf, 704.9 kb)

Article Citation

Lansing, Kevin J, Stephen F. LeRoy, and Jun Ma. 2018. "Examining the Sources of Excess Return Predictability: Stochastic Volatility or Market Inefficiency?," Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Working Paper 2018-14. Available at