Click here to open FedRing.
The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco

Community Investments Newsletter

Return to Current Index

Volume 11; No. 1; Winter/Spring 1999

What's Inside


NOTEBOOK by Joy Hoffmann Molloy

The world is changing rapidly and the approaching millenium looms large, bringing with it feelings of excitement and anticipation, and a number of issues whose outcomes will affect us all. One of the most critical issues for those of us in the community development field concerns the future of the Community Reinvestment Act.

As you may know, the CRA is again under scrutiny on Capitol Hill. One can only speculate what might happen in its absence, since most would agree that the CRA has significantly increased the flow of private capital into our nation’s poorest communities. In the article that follows, Andrea Levere makes an interesting point about the role of the CRA. Describing the recent surge of bank participation in revolving loan funds (RLFs), she observes, “The CRA is obviously a major force in encouraging bank investment in RLF’s; but while CRA may be what motivates banks initially, it is not necessarily what keeps them invested over time.” Indeed, the CRA’s ability to bring financial institutions to the table may be its greatest legacy.

For nearly fifteen years, the Federal Reserve’s Community Affairs Unit has been devoted to helping banks improve their CRA performance. We accomplish this through a myriad of products and services including technical assistance, educational seminars and conferences, banker roundtables, community profiles, and special projects. While the CRA and fair lending laws have been at the core of our work, our focus has expanded to include the vast landscape of community and economic development.

Community Investments is another vehicle through which community and economic development issues are presented. Each quarter, we try to strike the right balance between practical, theoretical, and cutting-edge information . . . all with an eye toward strengthening your “tool kit” of innovative ideas and opportunities. With a circulation topping 8,000, Community Investments is positioned to become the premier source of industry information in the 12th District. We’d appreciate your comments or ideas for future issues.

Whatever the outcome of the latest CRA debate, the Federal Reserve will continue to support community and economic development into the next millenium. In the meantime, we look forward to receiving your feedback on Community Investments and to assisting your community development efforts throughout the year.


Editor-in-Chief Joy Hoffmann Molloy
Managing Editor Shawn Elliott Marshall
Contributing Editor Jack Richards
Art Director Cynthia B. Blake
Production Coordinator Ariel Andres

Free subscriptions and additional copies are available upon request from the Community Affairs Unit, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, 101 Market Street, San Francisco, California 94105, or call (415) 974-2978.

Change-of-address and subscription cancellations should be sent directly to the Community Affairs Unit. Please include the current mailing label as well as any new information.

The views expressed are not necessarily those of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco or the Federal Reserve System. Material herein may be reprinted or abstracted as long as Community Investments is credited. Please provide the Managing Editor with a copy of any publication in which such material is reprinted..



To Community Investments

Welcome to the newest feature of Community Investments, a forum dedicated to the open exchange of information. To inaugurate our “Letters” column, we’ve decided to publish a selection of regulatory questions that we’ve received in the last month.

We look forward to publishing a dynamic, interesting and educational feature each quarter. Your letters and commentary will help make that possible. If you have a question, opinion or brief anecdote to share, please send it to the attention of Ariel Andres, production coordinator, by mail, fax or e-mail. The contact information is provided in the staff box located to the left. Best Regards, The Staff of CI

 

Q. W ill examiners review community devel-opment data from the time of the last exam or before? What kind of loan growth will they be looking for?

CI. Examiners will review community development data from your last exam forward. They will consider community development loan and investment growth relative to the overall growth of your bank’s portfolio.

Q. Our bank was recently asked to co-sponsor an affordable housing conference, but the conference venue isn’t located in a low- or moderate-income neighborhood. Does our sponsorship qualify?

CI. Your sponsorship is a qualified investment as long as the conference is specifically designed to address the community development needs (i.e. affordable housing, small business, economic development, etc.) of low-and moderate-income persons or neighborhoods.

Q. Our bank has been asked to finance the construction of multi-family units located in a low-income census tract, but affordable to middle-income households. Will we receive lending test credit?

CI. Your bank will receive lending test credit only if you can demonstrate that the devel-opment will stimulate additional investment to the area (a community or retail center, for example), thereby contributing to the stabilization and revitalization of the low-income community in which it is located.

Q. I am the CRA Officer of a credit card bank that offers only a narrow product line to a regional market (credit cards to businesses). I heard at a recent CRA roundtable that having a narrow product line doesn’t auto-matically give us a limited purpose designation. Will you explain?

CI. The person you heard at the CRA roundtable was correct. Having a narrow product line does not automatically render your institution Ælimited purpose’. In your case, your bank provides loans directly to businesses in the form of a credit card. Since these are not consumer credit cards, they are reportable as “commercial or industrial” loans for purposes of the Call Report. Furthermore, the regulation categorizes credit cards to businesses as small business loans. This type of retail lending product is examined under the lending test, which prevents your bank from receiving a limited purpose designation. Examiners are adept, however, at merging conventional CRA examination procedures into the context of a bank with a fairly narrow product line.

Q. Should our Assessment Area include loan production offices (LPOs)?

CI. Branch location is the primary means of establishing an Assessment Area. Since LPOs are not considered branches, the answer is no, unless your LPOs are in areas where your bank also has established branches. Although rumor has it that some regulatory agencies have been “more flexible” than others on this issue, the regulation is clear that non deposit-taking facilities should be excluded from a bank’s assessment area. We’ll let you know if and when this changes in the future.

Q. Where can I find information about credit needs within my assessment area?

CI. This depends on where you do business. In some rural areas, published information is difficult to track down, but not impossible. You might begin your search by calling your state’s department of rural development or a state association that focuses on rural issues. In urban areas, information sources are more plentiful. In either case, some of the best sources are local affordable housing developers and small business assistance providers. You might want to consider formalizing a program that regularly solicits feedback from key nonprofit organizations. This could be done through a periodic questionnaire or phone update. You might even consider developing an advisory group that meets regularly to discuss client-credit needs.

If your time is limited, consider checking the Census Bureau’s web page for demographic information by census tract (www.census.gov). These data can provide a good foundation for determining housing types and potential for multi-family, single-family, or mixed-use loans. If your bank is a member of the Federal Home Loan Bank System, you may want to review Affordable Housing Program grants to ascertain the types of projects being funded in specific areas. The web sites of state and local departments of commerce are also worth checking. Whatever you decide, create a long-range plan and regularly check the quality of your information to make sure that it’s: a) accurate, and b) enhancing your lending program.


Financial institutions not supervised by the Federal Reserve are encouraged to verify this information with their regulatory agency.

If you have an interesting community development program or idea, we would like to consider publishing an article by or about you. Please contact:

Managing Editor
Community Investments
Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
101 Market Street, Mail Stop 620
San Francisco, California 94105

(415) 974-2978 fax (415)393-1920